Skip to main content
GuidehouseGuidehouse
Guidehouse
  • Industries
    All Industries
    Industries
    • Communities, Energy & Infrastructure
    • Defense & Security
    • Financial Services
    • Health
    • State & Local Government
    Europe, Middle East & Canada

    Europe, Middle East & CanadaShaping industries with global scale

  • Services
    All Services
    Services
    • AI & Data
    • Energy & Resilience
    • Finance & Revenue
    • Managed Services
    • Mission Enablement
    • Operations & Efficiency
    • People, Organization & Change
    • Risk, Regulatory & Compliance
    • Technology
  • Insights
    All Insights
    Insights
    2026 Trends Guide
    • Energy Providers
    • Government Agencies
    • Financial Services
    • Health
    featured content

    The GuideLine podcast: Finding balance through fast tech and high stakes

  • Careers
    All Careers
    Careers
    • Early Career
    • Contractors
    • Experienced Professionals
    • Veterans & Military
    Help Guide the Future

    Search & Apply for Jobs

  • About
    About Guidehouse
    About
    • Community Impact
    • Government Contract Vehicles
    • D.C. United Partnership
    • Ecosystem Partners
    • Europe, Middle East & Canada
    • Legal
    • News & Events
    • Leadership
    • Privacy Policy
    Guidehouse in
    DeutschlandIndiaLietuvaUnited KingdomView offices
Article

Energy affordability, redefined 

Utilities need a new way to connect investment decisions to customers' pocketbooks by visualizing and quantifying both direct and indirect benefits. 

November 18, 2026
Aerial view of a tree-lined rural town with a sunlit road running through homes and fields at sunset
November 18, 2026

Summary

 

  • Individually justified investments can collectively create unmanageable bill impacts.
  • The Guidehouse Affordability Impact Navigator framework helps leaders see how portfolio choices affect customers over time before costs are committed.
  • Utilities can decide what to invest in, when, and how quickly with a clearer view of the tradeoffs for customers. 

 


 

Safe, reliable, affordable: That has long been the mantra of the electric power industry. But today’s utilities are facing investment needs and cost pressures that are making it hard to deliver on the first two of those promises without jeopardizing the third.  

The average retail electricity price in the U.S. across all sectors rose roughly 30% between 2020 and 2025, according to an analysis of EIA data published by Motive Power in partnership with the National Public Utilities Council. This bill pressure is hitting customers just as utilities are having to make historic investments in the systems that power our economy and everyday lives.

Data centers are a primary driver of this pressure. Electrification, storm hardening, aging-asset replacement, grid modernization, new technology, and cyber and physical security concerns are contributing to this dynamic as well. S&P Global forecasts that U.S. energy utilities’ capital expenditures from 2026 to 2023 will be nearly twice that of the prior five years (2021-2025). The affordability impacts of this spending surge can’t be ignored.

A utility’s leadership can make a sound business case for every major investment and still end up with a portfolio its customers can’t afford. This means that leaders need to do more than simply decide which projects deserve approval. They must choose the combination, sequence, and pacing of investments that will deliver essential outcomes at a cost customers can manage. The specific mix of cost pressures—and the utility’s ability to manage them—may vary by market, but customers experience their combined impact as a single bill.

These challenges call for approaching investment decisions in a new way by embedding affordability into planning, spending, and everyday operations. This approach must weigh not only near-term bill impacts but also the full costs, benefits, and risks customers experience over time.  

Utilities need to determine with confidence which investments create the greatest customer value, who pays for them, how long it will take for costs to impact bills, and whether households can manage those bills while they wait for the benefits to emerge—because a future system benefit doesn’t pay today’s household bill.

A future system benefit doesn’t pay today’s household bill.

Traditional prudency, project-benefit, cost, and rate reviews remain essential. The additional leadership task is to connect those reviews to the cumulative bill trajectory. Which costs are already committed? Where can scope, timing, delivery cost, or financing still change? And what happens when essential investment exceeds what customers can reasonably manage?

Deferring expenditure isn’t a cost-free answer, either. It can leave customers exposed to greater restoration costs, outages, and other downstream impacts. Affordability must inform these choices, not merely tally their consequences.

 

A broader approach to meet the moment

To meet these challenges, we’ve developed a flexible, comprehensive decision framework that helps utilities evaluate investment choices based on their full impact on customers. The Guidehouse Affordability Impact Navigator (GAIN) examines investment decisions through the lenses of what customers receive in return, when benefits arrive, and how costs, benefits, and risks are distributed. The goal isn’t simply to make a broader business case; it’s to offer a clearer choice among investment alternatives.  

This framework isn’t a software tool or a substitute for regulatory judgment. It’s a decision and governance methodology that connects investment decisions with customer and system outcomes. It’s intended to help utilities develop a defensible strategy that considers affordability through the following connected lenses that range in scope from narrow to broad:

  • Rates: What’s the investment’s impact on generation, transmission, distribution, and retail charges?  
  • Customer bill: In addition to rates, what’s the impact on fixed charges and volumetric usage?
  • Indirect energy costs: What’s the energy-related total cost of ownership, including equipment purchases, financing, maintenance, and other factors that can have an economic impact on residential and C&I customers beyond their utility bill?
  • Energy security: What are the reliability, safety, resilience, and supply impacts?
  • Societal impact: How will the investment affect public health, economic development, workforce opportunities, community resilience, and equity?

The level of emphasis placed on each lens must align to the particular jurisdiction and market structure. Where generation capacity decisions lie outside a utility’s control, actionable choices may concentrate on transmission and distribution rates. The GAIN framework allows utilities to focus on the total bill, including charges the utility can’t determine. By helping decision-makers separate controllable decisions from external drivers, GAIN makes accountability clearer without limiting the affordability discussion to the charges a particular utility can influence.

 

Balancing impact: An illustrative example

Consider a hypothetical utility evaluating flood barriers and elevation of critical substation equipment after repeated flood-related outages. GAIN supports immediate protection of the highest-risk sites while showing that accelerating the entire program would concentrate bill increases in the same period as other committed investments.

The utility's executives are able to compare designs and sequences, assess the residual flood risk, and distinguish bill effects from avoided customer disruption and broader community benefits without double-counting. They determine that a phased program might moderate near-term bill impacts but could prolong exposure or increase total costs.

GAIN helps the team determine which substations to protect first and how quickly to phase the remaining work, balancing near-term bill impacts against continued flood exposure and total program costs.

 

Moving affordability upstream

A utility bill represents an outcome, not a decision. By the time impacts from enterprisewide decisions flow through to a customer bill, the major investment, financing, and cost allocations are already locked in. GAIN takes a holistic capital allocation approach that reframes the central question: What reliability, resilience, growth, security, and customer value does each dollar of bill impact deliver?

Designed to work alongside and enhance established planning tools and processes such as benefit-cost analysis, GAIN doesn’t challenge the basic pillars of cost-of-service ratemaking or the reliance on return-on-equity as an incentive to deploy capital. Applying the framework starts with identifying what’s driving projected customer bills, such as costs already committed, external pressures, or the investment choices that leadership can still influence. Leaders can then compare how feasible portfolios affect different customer groups over time rather than approve projects in isolation and calculate the total afterward.

The resulting outlook doesn’t guarantee an affordable bill or replace safety and reliability obligations. But it gives leaders the opportunity to identify where essential work creates pressures that customers may struggle to manage. By examining scope, financing, timing, and customer protections, leaders can make the consequences of each option clearer to inform decision-making instead of simply deferring required investments.

This helps bring near-term costs and downstream benefits into focus through a customer affordability lens by distinguishing fixed charges from variable charges, and class averages from specific customer segment experiences. A portfolio may appear manageable on average while creating acute burdens for vulnerable customers. Assistance, access to efficiency measures, and appropriate rate protections figure into each GAIN assessment, taking into account who can participate and who remains exposed.  

 

Evaluating the portfolio, not just its parts

Individually affordable projects can overlap in their recovery periods and compete for delivery capacity or enabling infrastructure. That’s why testing only a central forecast is insufficient. Load growth, interest rates, fuel prices, extreme weather, security events, and customer adoption can each change cost and benefit calculations. Stress-testing should reveal whose bills are most exposed, which assumptions drive that exposure, and what actions remain available if conditions change.  

GAIN helps utility leaders make consistent evaluations that examine project, program, and portfolio choices across costs, customer impacts, broader economic effects, risk, and societal outcomes. Related investments should be considered together when one enables another’s benefits. And alternatives should be considered on the basis of different scopes and sequences rather than approval or rejection of a preferred project. This makes the balance between upfront costs, downstream benefits, and avoided expenditure explicit while preserving differences that an aggregated benefit-cost result can conceal.

Consider another hypothetical utility, this one comparing a feeder upgrade, targeted demand response, and enabling control-system investment. By reviewing these projects in isolation, leaders could miss that the demand response option depends on the controls, or that an upgrade remains necessary for safety regardless of peak-demand reduction. Under the GAIN framework, conducting a combined assessment would involve comparing credible sequences, testing participation and load assumptions, and showing the timing of bill effects and benefits. It also wouldn’t presume that a technology-led or infrastructure-led solution is always preferable.

 

Asking hard questions about value

The GAIN methodology is designed to help decision-makers pull the right investment levers at the right time to create the greatest overall value while managing affordability impacts. Because it can be applied in specific ways to specific categories of investment, it helps leaders center actions around a critical question for each of the following investment categories.

Electrification and load growth. What’s the affordability cost of accepting each load commitment, and who bears it? Expected growth may spread costs, but that outcome depends on timing, utilization, and the investment required to serve it.

Energy efficiency. What actual impact does a "nega-watt" from an energy-efficiency or DSM program have on affordability? Avoided consumption isn’t inherently the best investment in every location or period.

Flexibility. To what extent will virtual power plants, demand response, and distributed energy resources drive affordability outcomes? These levers should be assessed against the flexibility they can actually deliver—when and where needed—after participation and operating costs are factored in.

Technology. How do IT/OT and AI investments impact customers? Utilities need a clear path to customer outcomes, not a business case resting on novelty.

Low-income assistance. How can utilities protect the most disadvantaged customers? Utilities need a clear view of how their investments affect the energy burden of vulnerable households.

Storm hardening and grid resilience. What’s the affordability impact of storms, and how can it be mitigated by resilience investments? Resilience decisions require a full accounting of storm costs, including restoration expenditure, asset damage, service disruption, and consequences to customers and communities.

Regulatory and rate innovation. How can regulatory mechanisms protect affordability and incentivize affordability outcomes? Recovery arrangements, performance expectations, and incentives must simultaneously protect customers and remain consistent with service obligations and jurisdictional regulatory frameworks.

The subsequent articles in this series will examine how a more comprehensive decision framework can help utilities answer these questions so that they can manage the affordability impact of their investments in each of these areas.  

When applying the GAIN framework to any of these investment types, benefit-cost analysis remains essential but isn’t exhaustive. It helps distinguish monetized effects from nonmonetized considerations and clearly surfaces assumptions, uncertainty, and distributional impacts. Counting an avoided cost across several categories can exaggerate value; assigning precise numbers to weak evidence can do the same. GAIN broadens the questions asked without challenging cost-of-service regulation or return-on-equity incentives.

 

Making affordability a governing discipline

GAIN is most useful when affordability becomes a central part of planning, prioritization, regulatory filings, and accountability rather than a standalone study or after-the-fact communications exercise. Building that discipline starts by taking the following practical governance steps.

  1. Set baseline objectives and develop a customer affordability outlook showing how costs and investment choices affect different customer groups over time.
  2. Prioritize and sequence investment options using a consistent framework that evaluates all affordability impacts.
  3. Refine and “right-size” projects and programs to optimize affordability.
  4. Stress-test the proposed investment portfolio and document the tradeoffs.  
  5. Create accountability by tying business unit and executive objectives to affordability outcomes—and evaluate those outcomes all the way through approved solution delivery and beyond.  
  6. Update forecasted and actual bill impacts periodically alongside reliability, resilience, and customer outcomes. Take actions to mitigate risks and issues.  
  7. Measure and review affordability outcomes and be willing to share the results with regulators and customers.
  8. Use gathered evidence to inform the next planning cycle, including whether to adjust scope, change sequencing, strengthen protections, or revise assumptions.

Your next capital planning exercise shouldn’t result in a stack of individually justified projects. It should result in a clear view of the total affordability impact, including bill trajectory, alternative choices, and selected portfolio consequences for customers. GAIN connects those factors to customer value by making cumulative impacts and tradeoffs visible. This helps leaders explain not only why an investment deserves approval but why its scope, sequence, and pace are right for the customers funding it.

Michelle Fay, Partner

Ted H. Walker, Partner

RELATED INDUSTRIES

  • Communities, Energy & Infrastructure

More on this topic

  • The energy demand challenge: A catalyst for lasting change
  • Accelerating the Energy Cloud with AI
  • Rethinking the utility operating model in the AI era

Let us guide you

Guidehouse is a global AI-led professional services firm delivering advisory, technology, and managed services to the commercial and government sectors. With an integrated business technology approach, Guidehouse drives efficiency and resilience in the healthcare, financial services, energy, infrastructure, and national security markets.

Get in touch with our experts:

Stay ahead of the curve with our latest insights, expertly tailored to your industry.

Logo

outwit complexity™

Logo

outwit complexity™

Connect with us

Industries

  • Communities, Energy & Infrastructure
  • Defense and Security
  • Financial Services
  • Health
  • State & Local Government

Services

  • AI and Data
  • Energy & Resilience
  • Finance & Revenue
  • Managed Services
  • Mission Enablement
  • Operations
  • People Organization & Change
  • Risk, Regulatory & Compliance
  • Technology

About

  • Community Impact
  • D.C. United Program
  • Ecosystem Partners
  • General Inquiries
  • Government Contract Vehicles
  • Legal / Policies
  • Our Leadership
  • Privacy Policy
Insights
Careers
News & Events
Offices
  • Guidehouse In
  • Deutschland
  • India
  • Lithuania
  • United Kingdom
  • Privacy Notice for CA Residents
  • Modern Slavery Statement
  • Do Not Sell / Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Settings & Do Not Sell My Personal Info
  • Global Human Rights Statement

© 2026 Guidehouse