When to assess climate risk in capital projects
With assets that will operate for 30 to 50 years, assessing climate change risks at precisely the right time is crucial.
Summary
- Climate risk assessments for capital projects are most cost-effective when they can be built early into design, contracts, and financing instead of added as an afterthought.
- By learning the lessons that help identify the right time to assess climate risks, leaders can reduce costs, minimize late-stage changes, and support long-term reliability.
In December 1999, a combination of high winds and the incoming tide overwhelmed the protective seawalls of the Blayais nuclear plant on the west coast of France. Water flooded the rooms beneath the reactors, knocking out the plant's off-site power supply and several safety-related systems.
Eighteen months earlier, the plant’s own safety review had recommended that the seawalls be raised from 5.2 to 5.7 meters. The work was planned but delayed to save time and money. In the end, the disaster prompted fundamental changes to flood risk evaluations across France’s nuclear power plants, with resulting costs in billions of euros.
While Blayais was an extreme case, it’s clear that it’s less expensive to address climate risks in early design phases than to make corrections once a project has advanced further. In a previous Guidehouse article about capital project climate risk considerations, we noted that making assessments early in the design process can reduce costs and convey other benefits. By exploring lessons from several specific projects, we can develop real-world evidence to better determine the ideal timing and level of detail for climate risk analysis.
Lessons from problematic projects
In each of the following examples, climate risk analysis was too limited, too late in the process, or both.
Blayais: Early assessment, limited depth. The plant was originally built to withstand a one-in-10,000-year flood event. But that standard didn’t conceive of a storm surge arriving at the same time as a high tide—a combination that fell outside the design scope. What stands out is the vast difference between the estimated cost of prevention and the actual cost of remediation. The safety review recommendation of raising the protective seawall by half a meter was a relatively small mitigation measure that wouldn’t have cost much if implemented in a timely fashion.
In contrast, the eventual cost of waiting was huge, resulting in a full review of flood protection at every nuclear plant in France, changes made at each site, and billions spent guarding against such extreme events. One mitigating factor was that the Blayais project was undertaken before climate adaptation had become a common part of project planning. Today, that risk is treated as a baseline nuclear safety issue. The takeaway is that this project failure reflects what can ensue if climate risk mitigation is neglected.
Exeter: Right depth, late timing. A low-carbon district heating center in southwest England faced strong objections during the permitting phase because the project’s chosen site was in a flood zone. The operator responded with a substantial redesign, raising the main building above the ground and adding backup systems. The analysis that led to these changes was sufficiently thorough—but it was prompted by external comments and took place after the design had been largely settled. This necessitated an expensive late-stage redesign that wouldn’t have been necessary for a site with a lower risk of flooding.
Hinkley Point C: Early assessment without sufficient adaptation. This nuclear plant’s flood protection design was set during 2012 using the then-current Reference High Sea Level (RHSL) as the basis for precautions. With a margin of 1.08 meters between the RHSL and the site platform, the design was considered sufficiently conservative. But project leaders finalized the figures on which designs were based early on, then treated the question as closed—even though later projections for rising sea levels were higher than those the design had relied on. An early assessment can create false confidence if its assumptions aren’t revisited.
Late-stage climate risk assessment mandates
Another key factor that plays into this problem is the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities, which is part of the European Commission’s efforts to create an EU-wide classification system. Under its sustainable finance rules, the “do no significant harm” principle means that projects must be checked for climate risks. Because lenders can make climate adaptation efforts a financing condition, a detailed climate risk analysis can be required once the project reaches the financing stage if one hasn’t already taken place. But at that point the design phase would be closed, making mitigation measures more costly. This conundrum and the examples described combine to form a pattern: Problems occur when risk assessment is too late, too limited, or both.
Benefits of a two-step approach
Most projects assess climate risk once, forcing a trade-off between timing and depth. Less design detail is available when assessment takes place very early in a project, making it limited. Deeper analysis is possible once more is known about the design, but any resulting mitigation changes become more difficult and costly.
But if two assessments are carried out, these issues can be avoided. Early screening influences design and siting, then targeted deep analysis happens once there’s more understanding of where to focus.
The first assessment should be undertaken while projects are still in the concept phase. This is a rapid hazard scan across many options, including all candidate sites and designs. It should focus on comparing relative risks to inform the site shortlist early, allowing operators to eliminate options that are clearly at higher risk from flooding, storm exposure, or other hazards before investment.
Then as options narrow, a full, in-depth compound/tail and lifetime analysis should be undertaken before the commitment stage. This should include a detailed assessment of compound events, extreme tails, and lifetime risks. It should also apply existing methods to refine key design choices such as elevation, protection, or cooling while changes are still feasible and cost-effective.
The figure below illustrates how climate risk assessment timing and depth can affect final mitigation activity costs and indicates the ideal timing for a two-step approach.
It’s logical to assume that conducting two assessments would cost more because it would involve more work. But because the early assessment is intended to be quick and inexpensive—allowing detailed analysis to be carried out only once against one or two viable designs—this targeted approach would likely entail lower overall costs than would a redesign during permitting or a retrofit during operation.
And with the EU’s sustainable financing rules resulting in climate risk assessment as a financing condition, assessing risk early when results can still shape design at a lower cost is preferable to doing so at a stage when changes become more expensive.
Even with a limited number of examples to learn from, the evidence is clear. A quick, early assessment can be used to eliminate weaker options, while a more thorough assessment of the final shortlist can still influence design at a manageable cost, minimize expensive retooling, and avoid costly changes during operation.